Thoughts on startups by investors that
fund them & entrepreneurs that run them

The Problem with Private Placement Memorandums (PPMs)

The sale of equity in private companies is regulated by the Securities Act of 1933, which requires that the company either register with the SEC or meet one of several exemptions (Reg D).  A Private Placement Memorandum (PPM) is a special business plan defined to meet an SEC exemption.  In most cases, those entrepreneurs choosing to raise capital using PPMs retain specialists (many of whom are lawyers) to write their PPMs – a rather expensive undertaking. I don’t fund new companies that have prepared PPMs for investment.  I am an angel investor, that is, an accredited investor who is assumed by the SEC and others to be sufficiently wealthy to afford to lose the investment and supposedly experienced enough to make good choices on fundable companies.  Angels, as group of accredited investors funding startup companies, are assumed to meet a Reg D exemption for purchasing equity in private companies.

Why don’t I encourage entrepreneurs to use PPMs or at least invest in those that do?  Like most angel investors, I have preferences for the terms and conditions of investment and intend to negotiate with entrepreneurs on those terms, such as valuation, company structure, the makeup of the board of directors, liquidation preferences and others. I have yet to read a PPM written for a startup company that meets the parameters we angels generally establish for funding new ventures.  For some reason, PPMs prepared by those specialists just don’t match the standardized term sheets now being used by angel investors.

I don’t like the terms offered in the PPM, why don’t I insist that the terms be changed to accommodate my partialities as an angel investor?  Sounds simple, huh?  Unfortunately, upon completion of the PPM, the first thing that entrepreneurs tend to do is sell shares to friends, family, friends of friends and other acquaintances.  Then, only after convincing a bunch of these “unsophisticated” investors to sign up and write their checks, the entrepreneur may approach an angel or group of angels.  The entrepreneur has already raised half or more of the cash required in this round and is eager to top off the round.  The PPM does not meet the investing terms and conditions of the angels.  The valuation is too high, or the PPM is written for common stock when it really should have been a preferred stock deal or other critical terms are not present in the PPM.  Since many unsophisticated investors have already funded part of the round, it becomes too complicated to renegotiate the terms of the deal. What do I mean by “too complicated?”

I think we would agree that it is only fair that all capital sources in a given round should invest under the same terms and conditions.  There should not be one version of terms for the early set of investors (the PPM terms) and a second version of terms for later investors in the same round.  In the long term, different term sheets for investors in the same round leads to unhappy investors.  We angels could insist that the entrepreneur go back and renegotiate the terms of the PPM with all the earlier investors, but the earlier investors may or may not agree to the changes.  From a long history of angel investing, we have learned it is just easier to pass on PPM deals and move on to the next opportunity.  We see many startup investment deals every year – too many for most of us to fund.

Regarding PPMs, my recommendations to entrepreneurs are:

  • Don’t prepare PPMs to fund startup rounds of investment.  It is expensive and may preclude sophisticated investors from funding your deal.
  • Pursue smart money, that is, sophisticated investors who will negotiate a fair deal with you and help you grow your company.
  • Limit your offering:  Only sell shares to accredited investors.  In the long run, this usually works best for startup entrepreneurs.

Written by Bill Payne

user Bill Payne Angel Investor ,
Frontier Angel Fund

Bill Payne has been actively involved in angel investing since 1980. He has funded over 50 companies and mentored over 100. He is a founding member of four angel organizations: Aztec Venture Network, Tech Coast Angels, Vegas Valley Angels, and Frontier Angel Fund.

prev next

You might also be interested in

The UrbanTech Movement is Transforming Cities

Urbanization is a defining process of modern life.

More than half of the world’s population now lives in cities, and the number of urban citizens around the world is projected to rise to 66% by 2050.

In the US, over 80% of the population lives in urban areas with 1 in 7 Americans living in New York, Los Angeles and

Read more >

Angel Investors Spotlight: An Inside Look at Hudson Valley Startup Fund’s Investment Process & Advice for Founders

Hudson Valley Startup Fund brings together a network of the region’s successful business and community leaders to give back, supporting the launch of the next Hudson Valley visionaries. We sat down with fund managers Chad Gomes, Johnny LeHane and Paul Hakim as they shared insights into their investment process, what they look for in both group members and startups, and

Read more >

The Right Startup Advisors Are As Valuable As Money

If you are a new entrepreneur, or entering a new business area, it’s always worth your time to assemble an Advisory Board of two or three executives who have travelled that road before. You need them before you need funding, and if you select the wrong people, or use them incorrectly, no amount of money will likely save your startup.

Read more >

How do I get in touch with investors/funds with just an idea and no product?

There are many wonderful ideas, and they are not necessarily easy to come up with. So congratulations on having thought of one!

However…

“Having value” and “Being fundable” are two completely different things. What the more experienced responders here are saying is completely accurate: while a good idea is usually a necessary ingredient for the formation of a good company, it is

Read more >

Is there an incubator for aspiring Angel Investors or VCs?

No, but there are several sets of courses on angel investing that can provide a good base from which to start. The most comprehensive and best known is the Power of Angel Investing seminar series developed by the Angel Resource Institute (formerly known as the Angel Capital Education Foundation, and prior to that part of the Angel Capital Association). It

Read more >

Comments

2 thoughts on “The Problem with Private Placement Memorandums (PPMs)”

  1. Jeremy says:

    Hi Bill,

    I completely agree with you and think all investors in a round should have a single terms sheet.  One thing I am curious to see play out is how the crowdfunding space takes care of this issue being that there will be many players and investors involved.

    Jeremy

  2. Darryl says:

    I beg to differ, Bill. Nowadays entrepreneurs are eager to get funding by any means necessary and, like myself, hate a bunch of hoops and other unnecessary requirements to get the investor capital. The Frontier Angel Fund criteria is a perfect example: “We back early-to-mid-stage companies in the (Montana) region”! That means that you also pass on much more deals outside your area too. Relax your criteria and look for solid opportunities nationwide instead.